Home
Korean Sitemap
 


[23] 2008.12.22
Consumers' Choice of the Year 2008: Best Rice Brands



#701, Seoul YWCA, 1-1, Myeongdong 1-ga, Jung-gu, Seoul  (Postal code: 100-021)

    

Press Release


Date of Release: December 22, 2008
Phone: 82-2-774-4050, Fax:82-2-774-4090
Contact: Lee Jeong-su, Secretary General
Park Hyo-jin, Secretary

 

Consumers' Choice of the Year 2008: Best Rice Brands

 

In the 6thannual evaluation of high-quality brand rice by KNCCO(Chairman Kim Cheon-ju), "Keundeurae Kkum" presented by Daeya Agricultural Cooperative in Gunsan City, Jeollabuk-do was voted the best brand rice of the year by garnering 799.2 points out of the total 900 points. Superior brands include "CheolSaeDoRaeJi Rice" (Jaehee RPC) meaning "rice grown in a stopover site for migrant birds", of Gunsan City, Jeollabuk-do, "Dream SaengMi"(Dong-Gang Agricultural Cooperative) of Naju City, Jeollanam-do, Chemical-Free Horizon Rice(SaeManGeum Farming Co.) of Gimjae City, Jeollabuk-do, "Green Tea Beauty Boseong Rice"(Rice Cooperative Joint Corporation, Boseong Agricultural Cooperative) of Boseong-gun, Jeollanam-do, and "Rice Grown with Crakes"(Daesan RPC). Recommended brands are "Butterfly Rice"(Rice Cooperative Joint Corporation, Hampyeong Agricultural Cooperative) of Hampyeopnggun, Jeollanam-do, "Super Oning Rice"(Anjung/Songtan/Paengseong Agricultural Cooperative) of Peyongtaek City, Gyeonggi, "Cheongwon Saengmyeong Rice"(Rice Cooperative Joint Corporation, Cheongwon Saengmyeong Agricultural Cooperative), "Watermill Jinmi"(Gunyang RPC) of Gimcheon City, Gyeongbuk, "Hanaru Rice"(Dangjin Regional Agricultural Cooperatives Federation) of Dangjin-gun, Chungnam, and "Hannunebanhan Rice(Okcheon Agricultural Cooperative) of Haenam-gun, Jeollanam-do).

The previous evaluations that were performed between 2003 and 2007, included as qualified candidates only the rice that was produced in the preceding year and available on the market. As a result, rice that was produced and marketed in the current year of evaluation were excluded, which many have pointed out should be addressed. However, this year's evaluation will include rice that was produced both in the previous and current years in order to provide more accurate and practical information to consumers. In addition, experts and consumers visited the production sites and conducted a field evaluation, thereby making the evaluation process more scientific and consequently enhancing objectivity and reliability of the evaluation

According to an analysis of the evaluation results during the 6 years from 2003 to 2008, rice brands that are well-known among consumers and enjoy considerable brand power such as Icheon Rice and GyeonggiMi ranked low in the evaluation and were not voted among the 12 superior brands.

The 2008 brand rice evaluation found that cultivar purity has greatly improved from last year as a result of continued quality control efforts by rice producers.

Out of total 48 brands presented for the high-quality brand rice evaluation, 12 brands were selected as the outstanding brands of 2008 including one best brand, five superior brands, and six recommended brands.

The results will be announced at the "2008 Comprehensive Review of the Brand Rice Evaluation Project" to be held at the aT center on December 22, followed by an awards ceremony. The12 selected brands will be granted the awards from the Minister of Food, Agriculture, Forestry, and Fisheries, and memorial plaques by the chairman of the KNCCO.

The following is the details of the evaluation results.

12 outstanding brands of the year 2008 ◇
 

 ○ Best Brand(1) :

Keundeurae Kkum(Gunsan, Jeollabuk-do)

 ○ Superior Brands(5) :

Cheolsaedoraeji Rice(Gunsan, Jeollabuk-do)

Dream Saengmi(Naju, Jeollanam-do)

Chemical-Free Horizon Rice(Gimjae, Jeollabuk-do)

Green Team Beauty Boseong Rice(Boseong, Jeollanam-do)

Rice Grown with Crakes(Seosan, Chungcheongnam-do)

Recommended
Brands(6)
  :

Butterfly Rice(Hampyeong, Jeollanam-do)

Super Oning Rice(Pyeongtaek, Gyeonggi)

Cheongwon Saengmyeong Rice(Cheongwon, Chungcheongbuk-do)

Watermill Jinmi(Gimcheon, Gyeongsangbuk-do)

Haenaru Rice(Dangjin, Chungcheongnam-do)

Hannunebanhan Rice(Haenam, Jeollanam-do)

 


 

Reference

1. Evaluation Procedure

49 brands are recommended as candidates
(city, provincial governments, related associations)

Samples are collected
and sent for evaluation

(KNCCO)
- National Council of the Green Consumer Network in Korea

° Sales of a recommended candidate brand should be at least 2 billion won in 2007 with a sales target of 3 billion won for 2008.  

° Samples are taken randomly by the packaging unit at retail outlets.
° Samples were assigned random numbers 4 times at one-month interval and then repackaged for tests by experts.

 

 

Grade Evaluation
(National Agricultural Products Quality Management Service)

Eating Quality Evaluation
(Korea Food Research Institute)

° Grade by Appearance Evaluation
 - Evaluation Items : 11
 - Sensory Test Items : 3

° A panel of experts ran objective sensory tests to evaluate quality.

 

 

Cultivar-Blending Ratios Analysis
(National Agricultural Products Quality Management Service)

Paper-Based and Field Evaluations
(KNCCO)
-Citizens' Alliance for Consumer Protection

° Identification of Cultivar-Blending Ratios by DNA Analysis
 - to check if labels were matched with actual contents.
 - Points were deducted according to the ratio of other rice cultivars mixed in with the rice brand.

° Field Visits for Confirmation after Sample Tests
 - Contract-based production, contracted farming households management
 - Management of high-quality rice production facilities
 -Brand quality control

 

 

Consumer Satisfaction Survey
(KNCCO)
- Consumers Union of Korea

 

 

° A panel of 90 average consumers cooked each brand rice the same way they cook at home and subjectively evaluated them for taste, smell, appearance and other factors.

 

 

2. Analysis of Evaluation Results

1) "Keundeurae Kkum"(the Dream of the Grand Field) was voted the best brand rice of the year by garnering 799.2 points out of the total 900 points.

By region, Jeollanam-do toped the list with 4 locally-grown brands voted among the 12 award-winning brands, followed by Jeollabuk-do with 3 brands, Chungcheongnam-do with 2 brands, and Chungcheongbuk-do and Gyeongsangbuk-do with one brand, respectively.

2) The average score of the outstanding brands was 680.4 points. The average score of 680 points(75.6%) out of total 900 points, is slightly lower compared to 1,004 points out of 1,200 in 2007.

Category

Average Scores of Best brand Rice

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

Evaluation Item

51

61

71

50

51

48

Average Score

763.8

1,035.9

1,071.1

932.5

1,004

680.42

Percentage(%)

76.4

74.0

76.5

84.8

83.7

75.6

Total

1,000

1,400

1,400

1,100

1,200

900

3) Of the 12 brands, six brands had been voted among the outstanding brands from 2003 through 2007 and the other six brands were newly listed. Of the newly listed brands, 2 brands were grown in Jeollanam-do, and one in Jeollabuk-do, Gyeonggi-do, Gyeongsangbuk-do and Chungcheongnam-do, respectively.

Ranking

Category

Brand

Region

Producer

Previous records

1

Best Brand

Keundeurae Kkum

Gunsan,
Jeollabuk-do

Daeya Agricultural Cooperative

Newly listed

2

Superior Brands

Cheolsaedoraeji Rice

Gunsan,
Jeollabuk-do

Jaehee RPC

Listed 4 times as superior brands(2005, 2006, 2007, 2008)

3

Dream Saengmi

Naju,
Jeollanam-do

Donggang Agricultural Cooperative

Listed 3 times as superior brands (2006, 2007, 2008)

4

Chemical-Free Horizon Rice

Gimjae,
Jeollabuk-do

Saemangeum Farming Co.

Listed twice(2007, 2008)

5

Green Tea Beauty Boseong Rice

Boseong,
Jeollanam-do

Rice Cooperative Joint Corporation, Boseong Agricultural Cooperative

Newly listed

6

Rice Grown with Crakes

Seosan,
Chungcheongnam-do

Daesan RPC

Listed twice(2007, 2008)

7

Recommended Brands

Butterfly Rice

Hampyeong,
Jeollanam-do

Rice Cooperative Joint Corporation, Hampyeong Agricultural Cooperative

Newly listed

8

Super Oning Rice

Pyeongtake, Gyeonggi-do

Anjung/Songtan/Paengseong Agricultural Cooperative

Newly listed

9

Cheongwon Saengmyeong Rice

Cheongwon-gun, Chungcheongbuk-do

Rice Cooperative Joint Corporation, Cheongwon Saengmyeong Agricultural Cooperative

Listed 3 times(2003, 2006, 2008)

10

Watermill Jinmi

Gimcheon, Gyeongsangbuk-do

Gunyang RPC

Newly listed

11

Haenaru Rice

Dangjin, Chungcheongnam-do

Dangjin Regional Agricultural Cooperatives Federation

Newly listed

12

Hannunebanhan Rice

Haenam, Jeollanam-do

Okcheon Agricultural Cooperative

Listed 6 times(2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008)

 


 

A Comprehensive Review of the 2008 High-Quality Rice Evaluation Project

 

Date

11 am-12 am, December 22(Tuesday), 2008

 

 

Venue

the Grand Conference Room, aT Center(5th floor)

Program Order •

MC: Lee Jeong-su, Secretary General, KNCCO

Opening Ceremony

 

National Anthem & Pledge to the National Flag

 

Opening Remarks

Kim Cheon-ju, Chairman, KNCCO

Congratulatory Remarks

Park Deuk-bae, Second Vice Minister, Ministry of Food, Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries

Project Summary Briefing

Lee Jeong-soo, Secretary General, KNCCO

Results of the Evaluation

Lee Deuk-seung, Permanent Representative, National Council of the Green Consumer Network in Korea

Awards Ceremony

Park Deuk-bae, Second Vice Minister, Ministry of Food, Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries

Presentation of Memorial Plaques

Kim Cheon-ju, Chairman, KNCCO

 

Attachment: Results of the 2008 High-Quality Brand Rice Evaluation by Category

Ranking

Category

Brand

Grade

Eating Quality(experts' evaluation)

Cultivar

Eating Quality(consumers' evaluation)

Field Evaluation

Total Score

Percentage(%)

1

Best Brand

Keundeurae Kkum

190.2

168.1

199.4

148.5

93.0

799.2

88.8

2

Superior Brands

Cheolsaedoraeji Rice

199.1

166.7

200.0

134.1

94.5

794.4

88.3

3

Dream Saengmi

194.3

161.4

200.0

130.9

89.0

775.6

86.2

4

Chemical-Free Horizon Rice

188.3

153.6

200.0

137.8

95.0

774.7

86.1

5

Green Tea Beauty Boseong Rice

191.7

156.3

199.4

140.3

86.2

773.9

86.0

6

Rice Grown with Crakes

192.4

165.0

190.7

139.9

84.2

772.2

85.8

7

Recommended Brands

Butterfly Rice

196.0

152.2

199.4

130.9

93.7

772.2

85.8

8

Super Oning Rice

186.4

162.4

200.0

130.1

93.3

772.2

85.8

9

Cheongwon Saengmyeong Rice

190.2

154.2

200.0

136.9

90.0

771.3

85.7

10

Watermill Jinmi

190.2

161.8

196.7

139.5

79.0

767.2

85.2

11

Haenaru Rice

187.0

157.4

198.4

154.1

70.0

766.9

85.2

12

Hannunebanhan Rice

175.4

152.5

196.1

146.3

92.7

763.0

84.8


Member Organizations 

National Council of the Green Consumers Network in Korea, Young Women's Christian Association of Korea, Korean Federation of Housewives' Clubs, Citizens' Alliance for Consumer Protection, National Council of Homemakers' Classes, Korea Consumer Education Center, Consumers Union of Korea, Korean Federation of Young Men's Christian Associations, Korea Consumer Affairs Institute



#524, #525, 47, Sejong-daero 23-gil, Jongno-gu, Seoul (Postal code: 03182)
  TEL 82-2-774-4050   FAX 82-2-774-4090   E-mail: sohyub@consumer.or.kr